Clan
Sinclair
[Clan Sinclair]
History
Early
   Modern
   History
[up]
[prev] [next]
K. Peter's
   Crusade
   1365
Zeno
   Map
   (1398)
King of Scots
   James IV
   entertains
   Perkin
   Warbeck
   1495
B. Flodden
   1513
B. Summerdale
   1529
B. Solway
   Moss
   1542
B. Altgawn
   1586
B. Kringom
   1612
[Swedish Sinclairs]
   Sweden
Battle of
   Altimarlach
   1680
Sponsor:
Q

The Battle of Altimarlach and the Last Clan War, 1680

Of Castles, Clans and Campbells:
The Last Clan War

From: "Neil Sinclair/Peggy Rintoul" rinsin@globalserve.net
Date: Fri, 12 Mar 1999 14:41:50 -0500

Dear list members and those concerned with clan wars;

I glanced through my personal emails from the list this afternoon and noted some confusion around the Campbell-Sinclair and castle side. Perhaps a restatement would be helpful.

I am satisfied from most of the clan histories of Scotland that the last clan war was between Campbell of Glenorchy (The Duke of Argyll Line) and the Sinclairs of Caithness. But before everyone starts frowning let me share the rest of the Story.

The Sinclair estate was (prior to any clan war), virtually bankrupt. George borrowed from the Campbells among others to shore up the estates. You must remember because of changing economic conditions many clans were no longer surviving economically. In fact by the end of 1600 the country was 6 years away from the Act of Union and 45 years from the legal abolishment of the clan system. This all said the Campbells came to differences over this amount of debt owed to them and marched to collect it from George. That was quite a hike. There was a battle but if you are thinking along the Braveheart lines you may be mislead. We have a handful on each side not every man available at arms. The Sinclairs plainly lost according to every history. The Campbells claimed Caithness and the Sinclair Estates as security and legal entitlement. They were after the rents naturally.

Having no other recourse George approached the Court of Scotland, I believe it was then the Privy Council equal to the House of Lords at the time. It was the only court that could address the matter and the highest court in the land. It turned out that the force of arms was dimly looked on by the court (quite rightly just as they do today) and the Estate was awarded back to Sinclair. (I have yet to find what happened to the debt.) This completed (it took some 3 years) the old feudal system could revert back to Sinclair again, but here too there was difficulty. The rent system was in disarray, the economy around Scotland collapsing and many clansmen were leaving to seek their fortune elsewhere. This was not limited to the Sinclairs, it occured commonly with many Clan Chiefs actually paying their clansmen to leave to the cities and join the cotton making rush. Others were simply told to leave. For that manner many clan chiefs were not living in Scotland, but in London ready to educate their children at the best schools and live in a civilized manner away from the drafty castles of Scotland.

I wonder how the castle fell into ruins, it was not I believe done primarily by the Campbells but after a slow decline over 200 years of abandonment. There are sketches about 1800 of it and it was not nearly the ruin it is today.

One further irony, there was a new need for jobs and able workers to replace the many families now leaving for the Colonies and Australia. This being the case there was a turn around of the more prosperous estates. Workers, tacksmen, crofters and the tradespersons were sought from the cities and elsewhere. One such individual advertising was indeed, none other than our Duke of Argyll - John of Glenorchy.

And you might guess around 1700 who applied for the jobs of working on the farms near Auchindrain located in Inveraray. But a hardy band of Sinclairs. This was the forerunner of the Sinclair blood line in Argyll for the next 300 years. Oh and don't bad mouth the Campbells, not only were they our employers but they were also our lovers and many Sinclairs came to carry the Campbell blood line as well. Feuds between the Lairds really did not affect the more common folk, either then or now. That is the rest of the story.

Enough history for a Friday afternoon, keep up the reasearch constructive dialogues and have fun;

Yours aye yours

Neil Sinclair Toronto-PEI-Argyll

PS If you missed it, this summary was provided by Karen Matheson who has also studied the topic and popped this from the Tartan site.
"The direct line came to an end with George, 6th Earl who through debt granted the title and estates to Sir John Campbell of Glenorchy. In 1676, after Sir John assumed the title, George Sinclair of Keiss disputed the claim and seized the Caithness estates, only to be defeated in 1680 by the Campbells near Wick. Although the claim was lost by the sword, the Privy Council rendered his claim in 1681 and he became the 7th Earl of Caithness."
Note: The above is almost correct, but legally the grant of the lands was security for moneys, not a grant of title, but more along the lines of what many places consider a mortgage. I do not believe he moved away from the estate and hence the Campbells sought forceable possession. He resisted rather surprised I imagine that the Campbells were enforcing their claim. [Actually, the 6th Earl died before the Campbells tried to take posession.]

The Battle of Altimarlach

I picked up the following description of the Battle of Altimarlach at the Dunbeath Heritage Centre in Dunbeath. No author or source is noted. — Richard Huseth

The Battle of Altimarlach

Gaelic: Uilt na Muirleach—the Burn of the Thieves
(so called because of the plunder taken from the bodies of the dead)

The battle of Altimarlach was fought on 13th July 1680 between Sir John Campbell of Glenorchy and George Sinclair of Keiss over ownership of the Girnigoe Estates. A dispute arose over money alleged to have been borrowed by the 6th Earl of Caithness from Sir John who consequently laid claim to the estate and in 1677 was granted the title of Earl of Caithness, Lord Sinclair of Berriedale and Glenorchy. George Sinclair of Keiss, a close relative of the 6th Earl contested his claim and a series of disputes resulted in Glenorchy obtaining royal permission to invade Caithness to uphold his claim. He was also provided with several companies of the king's troops.

This army marched from Perth and arrived in Caithness on 18th May and set up camp at Braemore, near Morven, which at that time was on the Berriedale estate which Glenorchy claimed as Earl of Caithness. On 12th July he marched his army to the Hill of Yarrows, and the site was long known as Torran nan Gael, the Highlanders Hill. From there he had a commanding view of the area and decided to approach Wick under cover of a sudden mist. The mist lifted as he was coming down the Haster Burn and the alarm was raised by Sinclair's forces who were deployed in and around Wick.

Reports are confused but it seems that Glenorchy headed for Stirkoke and Altimarlach where he divided his force. Half were deployed on the haugh west of the burn and the others were concealed in the gully. When the Sinclairs came up Wick River to meet them, they were attacked by the group on the haugh, just where the burn met the river, and at the same time the ambush was sprung by the force in the gully. The Sinclairs were trapped against the river which is quite deep at this point and many men were drowned, or killed by the reserves if they managed to struggle to the opposite bank, on the Moss of Bronsie.

There is no accurate record of the number of men involved, but Glenorchy would have had about 800, and the Sinclairs a similar amount. Sinclair casualties were high with possibly 300 men killed. Many of the dead on the Campbell side were buried where the commemorative cross now stands. Peace was made between the sides the following day and was signed in the old Wick Town Hall which stood on the east side of the present Market Square.

The battle is notable for being the last major clan battle in Scotland and for the fact that two famous pipe tunes were composed by Glenorchy's piper Finlay Ban MacIvor, while the army was marching to Caithness. One was 'Breadalbane Gathering' and the other 'The Campbells are coming.' Until comparatively recently it was a gross insult to play these tunes in Wick."

Note that, in this account, there is no mention of the Sinclairs being drunk. — Richard Huseth

The Battle of Altimarlach

Gaelic: Uillt na Muirleach: the Stream of the Thieves

(so called because of the plunder which was taken from the bodies of the dead)

From: Niven Sinclair <niven@niven.co.uk>
Date: Mon, 12 Jul 1999 23:16:42 +0100

We usually think of the Massacre of Glencoe when we hear the name of Campbell being mentioned but it wasn't only the Macdonalds who had reason to fear and despise the Campbells.

The Sinclairs, too, had reason to hate the Campbells.

The Battle of Altimarlach was fought on 13th July, 1680 between Sir John Campbell of Glenorchy and George Sinclair of Keiss over the ownership of the Girnigoe Estates.

The dispute had arisen over money which the 6th Earl of Caithness was alleged to have borrowed from Sir John who laid claim to the Sinclair lands and, in 1677, was actually granted the title of the Earl of Caithness with the subsidiary title of Lord Berriedale by which the son of the Earl was invariably known.

George Sinclair of Keiss, a close relative of the 6th Earl, contested the claim which resulted in Glenorchy obtaining royal permission to invade Caithness — a strange situation as he was already in possession of Girnigoe Castle which Keiss proceeded to batter into ruins.

Glenorchy i.e. Campbell even obtained several Companies of the King's forces. This army marched from Perth and arrived in Caithness on the 18th May and set up camp at Braemore which lies snugly below Morven, the highest hill in Caithness. This was part of the Berriedale Estate which Glenorchy had laid claim to when he was made the Earl of Caithness.

On the 12th July he decided to move his army towards Wick and took possession of the Hill of Yarrows from where he had a commanding view of the road to the North. When a sudden mist came down he decided to approach Wick and take the town by surprise.

The mist lifted as his army came down the Haster Burn and the alarm was raised by Sinclair's forces which were deployed in and around Wick. Reports are confused but it would seem that Glenorchy headed for Stirkoke and Altimarlach where he decided to split his forces with half of them being positioned at the haugh* whilst the others were hidden in a convenient gully.

When the Sinclairs came up the Wick River to meet them they were attacked by the group in the haugh just where the burn meets the river and, at the same time, the others emerged from the gully. The Sinclairs were trapped against the Wick River which is quite deep at this point. Many of them were drowned and those who did manage to struggle to the opposite bank were killed by Glenorchy's reserves.

There is no accurate record of the number of men involved but it is thought that Glenorchy commanded some 800 men and the Sinclairs would have a simlar number. The Sinclair casualties were said to number 300 whilst the Campbells lost a mere handful. The Campbell dead were buried where the commemorative cross now stands.

Peace was made on the following day and was signed in the Old Wick Town Hall which stood on the East side of the Old Market Square.

The battle is notable for being the last major Clan battle in Scotland.
On the way North, Glenorchy's piper, Finlay ban McIvor, composed two tunes. One was called "Breadalbane Gathering" and the other was the notorious "The Campbells are Coming — the carls wi' the breeks are running before us". Needless to say, the "carls wi' the breeks" were the Sinclairs who had not yet taken to the kilt.
Until comparatively recently, these tunes were banned in Wick and, even today, it would be a brave man who tried his luck by whistling them!!

As a boy, I would recite the following poem:
"Short time, Glenorchy Caithness ruled
        By every rank abhorred,
  Whilst Keiss, who firm upheld the claim,
  Obtained the Sinclair's coronet,
  Which was his own by right
  And with that brave devoted band
  On fatal Flodden fell".

Again a few words of explanation might be necessary.  Earls and other nobility are invariably known by their titles rather than by their family name, hence: Glenorchy = Sir John Campbell whilst Keiss = George Sinclair.

When the Campbells sang "the 'carls' wi' the breeks are running before us", it was particularly insulting to the Sinclairs because 'carl' means a churl, a peasant or a low-bred person. The only other word which may cause difficulty is 'haugh' which is a flat piece of land along a river bed. The Sinclair Castle at Ravenscraig was once known as Ravenshaugh but the word 'haugh' fell into disuse.

Incidentally, as the battle of Flodden Field took place in 1513, the composer of the above poem was taking a bit of poetic licence when he suggested that the George Sinclair who took part in the Battle of Altimarlach fell at Flodden. True a George Sinclair of Keiss did fall at Flodden (along with 600 other Sinclairs) but he must have been the g.g.g.grandfather of the one who took part in the debacle of Altimarlach.

Other debacles in which the Sinclairs took part were the Battle of Summerdale (1528) when the Sinclairs of Caithness and the Sinclairs of Orkney slaughtered each other at the instigation of a Stewart monarch who feared Sinclair power and, once again, at Kringellen in Norway (1612) when a whole regiment of Caithness men were wiped out in an ambush. Paradoxically, Kringellen was the very area of Norway where we originated from in the first place.

Three disasters in a row. In less than 100 years, we lost nearly 2,000 men in futile battles. We were further weakened by our family feud with the Sutherlands. No wonder, we began to lose our pre-eminent position in the North of Scotland. No wonder so many Sinclairs escaped to find a new life in America and Australasia and, today, it is from those Continents that the Sinclair renaissance is taking place.

I believe the Internet has provided us all with a 'springboard of opportunity'. It has brought about a spiritual re-awakening of the Clan which is a pleasure to behold and a privilege to take part in.

Niven Sinclair

Last changed: 00/05/22 13:09:54 [Clan Sinclair]